If Jamies real mother was, in fact, Johns sister, it certainly seems like a strange thing to keep hidden now the biggest secret is out in the open. Season 5 airing Sundays on Paramount Network beginning November 13th, 2022. You don't see it on your way to work, in the fields, or on the mountain. U/Matthmil also pointed out that naming Jamie after the family founder could indicate he comes from the Dutton dynasty through blood. . Beth married longtime love Rip Wheeler in an unconventional ceremony in season 4. They havent said yet, so right now its anyones guess. Emma Dutton. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. We are led to believe that John takes boys in because of Rip but in this instance, Jamie is adopted and given the Dutton name. How different would Johns reaction have been if Evelyn Dutton were still alive? John's resentment of Jamie could come from bitterness that Jamie's father took away his sister from the ranch, which ultimately killed her. Only seen in flashbacks, Evelyn (Gretchen Mol) is John's wife and mother of Kayce, Beth, and Lee and adopted mother to Jamie. James's brother, Jacob (Harrison Ford), is the leader of the Dutton family in 1923. John Duttons family history is an intriguing aspect of the characters story. After coming home from work one day, Garrett was horrified to discover young Jamie crying and sucking on a crack pipe. In the second season finale, titled Sins of the Father, Johns father, John Dutton Jr (Dabney Coleman), plays a crucial role in underlining Johns fierce devotion to protecting his land. The secrecy of her or lack of info is fascinating to me. You know, when they try it themselves. He is a former soldier-turned-big game hunter who is called home from Africa to help his family defend their land. After being sentenced to jail, Garrett hoped that his son would have a better life with a different family who could love him and provide for him. NY 10036. Garrett previously claimed that he killed Jamie's birth mother to protect Jamie, but Garrett and John's history seemed to simmer with all kinds . Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! "The Yellowstone ain't a ranch, it's an empire," Garrett tells . Hes always moving all that stuff around.". Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab). From a story telling perspective, naming this character Jamie Dutton after the original patriarch, is foreshadowing that Jamie Dutton is a Dutton even though his birth father is not. Evelyn was far from a perfect mother in Yellowstone. Her mother, so distraught by the loss of her child, ends her own life. The historical drama 1883 is on Paramount Plus and it follows John Dutton's . A whole new can of worms to explore if T Sheridan wants to. Does John descend from Spencer's line and Jamie from John I and then Jack's?). The story goes that Jamie's biological father murdered his mother, and . He made that connection official when he married Beth. Something along the lines of, John getting mad at Jamie and saying, you are a Dutton and named for the man who claimed this land and created our legacy. He has not yet made an appearance in 1923, so his exact spot in the family tree is unclear. Margaret Dutton The show is trying pretty hard to tie in both spin-off shows and this could be another connection to 1883. In real life, however, Costner is happily married to designer Christine Baumgartner.As per People, the actor was married to Cindy Silva until they . I have my own theories, but its to be told, to be written, to be seen. She and John also adopted Jamie after his father killed his mother when he was young. "John also told Jamie that he begged Jamie's birth mother not to marry Garrett Randall because John knew what kind of man Garrett was. After learning the truth about his heritage, Jamie meets Garrett. He is one of at least three John's in the family, the others being his son, John Dutton Jr., and his grandson, John Dutton III. Furthermore, John rarely speaks about his mother making it difficult for us to understand the personality and nature of Johns mother. Hmmm this theory has been circulating on here for a while. This is America. Garrett was arrested in 1980 and convicted for the murder of his wife, Jamie's mother. When viewers meet her husband, John Dutton Jr, she appears to have passed away. I think it's more likely that she is John's wife's sister. ADVERTISEMENT I do think potentially that his mother worked on the ranch and that bio dad may have been a ranch hand and therefore the Duttons felt some responsibility for taking him in. Lee Dutton was shot by Robert Long in Season 1 of 'Yellowstone.'. Beth was nervous which caused her horse to spook the horse Evelyn was riding. The pair have 3 daughters together, and their names are Isla and identical twins Darcy and Ava. With John Dutton (Kevin Costner) opting to speak fairly little about his mother, viewers must be wondering about her identity and fate. Josh Lucas, who plays a young John Dutton in Yellowstone, talks about the impact of Evelyns death on his character. Thats all I can say. But who knows; that might end up coming up later but as of right now they havent really dove into who exactly she was.. Jamie still reminds John of his sister and the pain she caused the family so John maintains a bit of resentment. Eventually, Garrett even moves in with Jamie at his new home. John Dutton clearly was close to Jamies birth mother well before Jamie was born. It would be nice if Yellowstone surprised with the adoption revelation bringing John and Jamie closer together. Though some fans had follow-up thoughts, no one can deny that this would be information that would blow up Jamie's life. Heres how it works. "Yeah I knew him." Sketching a picture of his real father, John tells him, "When he married the woman who gave birth to you, we begged her not to do it . How Many Siblings Does He Have. Newsletter. During a moment of Beth's hesitation, Evelyn was bucked off her horse. When Jamie was looking at the court records, there were only a few months between her murder and Garrett's sentencing, so, maybe John didn't have a chance to "ship him off". Yellowstone Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Let her undo it. Its a pretty cruel thing to say to the young girl who obviously didnt mean for this tragedy to happen. Trending SR Exclusives Star Wars Marvel DC Star Trek The Last of Us The Mandalorian. .css-g0owdm{display:block;font-family:Memphis,Georgia,Times,Serif;font-weight:normal;margin-bottom:0.625rem;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-g0owdm:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 40.625rem){.css-g0owdm{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-g0owdm{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.2;}}@media(min-width: 61.25rem){.css-g0owdm{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;}}Kelsea Ballerini Confirms Relationship With Chase, See Lainey Wilson's Stunning Billboard's Look, Carrie Underwood Shares Hilarious Fashion Fail, See Jamie Lee Curtis Jaw-Dropping SAG Awards Look. Jamie's relationship with his family has always been rocky and learning that he was adopted only made things more complicated. Adopted son of John and Evelyn, Jamie (Wes Bentley) was raised as one of their own. However, Kevin Costners John Dutton is the Dutton familys present patriarch. However, it would make sense for the Duttons to adopt Jamie if his mother was somehow related to them. . On how John handled parenting Jamie, Kevin Costner said: But he was supported and Jamie's manufactured that I had never liked him, that I was never good to him, that's something that he's made up. John sees in Jamie the man who took his sister from the family and then murdered her. This is also the same character and actor (Tim McGraw) from the Native American burial flashback scene from the year 1893. Albeit Yellowstone did see John hold back from hurting Jamie after the reveal about what he did to Beth. My personal opinion is that John may be blinded in some ways concerning how he has genuinely treated Jamie. Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) is adopted. The Duttons adopted Jamie when he was only three months old and raised him as their own. Yellowstone: What secret has Beth Dutton kept since season 1? She has been writing about entertainment for 5 years, and as you may suspect, still finds it as entertaining to do as when she began. Jamie even introduces him to his child and his childs mother, Christina. DON'T MISS:James May opens up on pretty long days filming Grand Tour[EXCLUSIVE]Virgin River season 3 spoilers: Lizzie and Ricky romance sealed[INSIGHT]Lucifer fans tip season 6 time jump after episode title clues[THEORY]. The Yellowstone episode No Good Horses explains what happened to her. "Love this narrative," replied u/haroldhecuba88. By my memory, Jamie has not shared any such heart-warming stories about his own childhood. More info. Could John possibly hear Jamies side and be moved by it enough to accept that there's truth beyond his own? Moreover, she could have been related to Johns late wife Evelyn (Gretchen Mol), who was shown to have been crushed by a horse during a tragic flashback in the first season. During some of the most pivotal moments of the latest season, Jamie unearthed his birth records to discover ranch owner John Dutton (Kevin Costner) is not his biological father. In addition, the Duttons knew the Randalls, as they had known Phyllis before she married Garrett. Not Together Anymore? How Did John Know Jamie's Biological Mother? Her relationship to John Jr. and John III has not yet been revealed. He's. Free-spirited Alex ran away with Spencer in Africa. The death of a sibling . ET on Paramount Network. Claire (Dawn Olivieri) and her daughter Mary Abel join James and his family on their journey, but their story meets a tragic and brutal end. I find it so interesting we know nothing about John Dutton III's mother. Movie Features; Jamie's father struggled to make ends meet, and his mother struggled with a drug addict. As that period Western spinoff began, the Dutton family which consists of James, Margaret, and their children Elsa (Isabel May) and John (Audie Rick) are planning to move their family north. Kevin Costner has shared Johns clear perspective on his attempts at fatherhood, and to Johns credit, he has given Jamie a second chance after he betrayed his father on Yellowstone. It's unclear if John and Emma are also the parents of John Jr. James Badge Dale admitted to TV Insider that he's not sure how his character is related to John Jr. and therefore John III (Kevin Costner): "I have no idea. I just do not see it happening at the moment. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. After she wouldnt budge, he decided the only way out was to k*ll his father himself. Jamie Dutton was just three months old when he was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton. Phyllis Mary Randall was Phyllis Mary Dutton, Johns sister. However, Evelyns death changed the character in a big way. John Dutton IV (adoptive nephew) Appears in Yellowstone No. Why Did the Duttons Adopt Jamie? Jamie Dutton is the name of the Dutton patriarch that first claimed the land and founded the Yellowstone ranch. His intentions might have been there, but I do not think he has been as forgiving of Jamie as he has Kayce. During a flashback scene, fans found out why Beth hates Jamie so much. READ MORE:Yellowstone Jimmy star defends his disastrous decision in season 3. and Gil Birmingham, revolves around the life of John Dutton, the leader of America's largest contiguous ranch. Only problem is I cant imagine if a man murdered John Duttons sister he would still be living. It would be quite the coincidence that Jamie would be given that name unless his mother was a Dutton and named Jamie after her most important Dutton ancestor. There was a problem. John reveals to Jamie in season three of Yellowstone that he knew his mother,Phyllis, before she married Garrett Randall. Garrett has a vendetta against John for his wife Phyliss and for John not standing up for him in court. I think you hit the nail on the head. Kevin Costner Says Yellowstones Beautiful Locale Hides The Regions Dark History, Yellowstone Confirms the Relationship Status of This Power Couple, Steve Burton Announces His Return Date: Finally, the Time Has Come!, Thats That, Then: General Hospitals Maurice Benard Reveals Sonnys One True Love.